U.S. Presidents and the drive for Middle East peace
By Ray Hanania — What is it about Presidents who wait until the last minute to try and achieve peace in the Middle East? President George W. Bush is in Jerusalem meeting with Israelis and Palestinians to help nudge the latest generation of the “peace process” along. Why does this all sound so familiar? Bush is on the last leg of a presidential career. His final year. And all of a sudden, he wants to do all he can to bring about peace in the Middle East between Palestinians and Israelis.
I recognize that peace between Palestinians and Israelis is the Holy Grail of achievements for any American politician, despite all its political land mines and the wolf pack of lobbyists who nip and tear at anything remotely challenging to their vision of what needs to be done.
But why always so late?
It has to be ego, I think.
Former President Bill Clinton did the exact same thing eight years ago. The differences between Bush and Clinton are stark, of course.
Clinton spent his entire term in office pursuing the elusive achievement. But he made a massive push in the last few months during the twilight of his administration, just before leaving office.
Bush turned his back on Middle East peace from the day he stepped into office. Some might argue that he didn’t want to waste his time on a Gordian Knot so difficult that peace is impossible, but others might argue that he was so naïve and inexperienced he did not recognize how important the Middle East issues are on the American people.
He learned nine months later when Middle East terrorists led by Osama Bin Laden struck America on Sept. 11, 2001.
Yet, suddenly Bush is invigorated and wants to bring about peace?
All of a sudden?
Now?
I guess it is always better late than never. And I have to say that although Clinton was genuine in his desire for peace, Bush is being a little more even handed than Clinton.
In the final months of his push for peace, Clinton placed a pro-Israel activist, Dennis Ross, at the helm of the mission. Ross spent much of his time taking Israeli proposals at the Camp David meeting between Yasir Arafat and Ehud Barak, and presented them to the Palestinians as “American” ideas.
Very deceitful.
Clinton’s actions suggested the real motive was to lock in Jewish American support and votes for his wife, Hillary, who became a New York senator and is now in a cut-throat contest to become the Democratic nominee for President.
What’s in it form Bush?
Both men are deeply religious in different ways. Clinton more southern and passive in his Christian religion and Bush more conservative evangelist in his own reverence.
Yet what we have to be cynical at these times of pomp and ceremony when politicians are about ready to leave office.
Are they really chasing the elusive peace because they hope that by chance – like winning a lottery – they just might succeed and secure for themselves the greatest accolades in modern history?
Clinton wanted to leave office with a crown of achievement, although his selfish push in late 2000 before leaving office left the Middle East in a crown of thorns that turned into one of the worst periods of relations between Palestinians and Israelis in their tragic and shared history.
Is that what Bush wants? To leave office with some major achievement of substance? Is that all that Middle East peace is worth to the world, a trophy on some mantel of a presidential library, and a chapter in history books?
I hope Bush is successful. But it will take more than a president, even one who makes the daring trip to personally visit the Middle East as Bush is doing right now.
What Palestinians and Israelis need to achieve peace is a fair American president with a firm hand. You can’t leave it up to the two sides because the two sides have proven they won’t do it themselves.
President Bush needs to impose a peace, a peace agreement we all already know will consist of two-states, sharing Jerusalem, some apologies on both sides, compensation (mainly American tax dollars, of course) and a determination that can only come from inevitability that there is no way to avoid it.
Make it happen, Mr. President.
The world needs it. America needs it. And if it transforms your contentious seven years in office into something that dreams are made of, you would deserve it.
(Ray Hanania is a columnist and author. He can be reached at www.hanania.com. Copyright Arab American Writers Group Syndicate, www.ArabWritersGroup.com.)
January 9, 2008 -
Posted by
Ray Hanania |
Ray Hanania |
Bill Clinton, Ehud Barak, Ehud Olmert, elections, George W. Bush, Israel, Mahmoud Abbas, Middle East conflict, Palestine, peace, President Bush, President Clinton, push for peace, Yasser Arafat |
No Comments Yet
RAY HANANIA is a syndicated columnist. His columns appear in numerous publications including the Jerusalem Post, the Arab News, the Arab American News, the Southwest News Herald and more. Hanania is the publisher of the National Arab American Times Newspaper. Named Best Ethnic American Columnist for 2007 by the New America Media, and the 2009 Mehdi Courage in Journalism Awardee, Hanania hosts a morning Radio Show of Radio Chicagoland, in Chicago (Mon-Fri, 8-9:30 am) on WJJG 1530 AM Radio. He is an internationally acclaimed standup comedian, author of the humor book Ya Habibi, and pens the Comic Strip called Shades of Gray. View his complete Bio?
ANISA MEHDI is an Emmy Award-winning journalist specializing in religion, the arts, and people. For over 20 years she has reported, written, directed and produced television news and documentary programs for major American media outlets, including National Geographic, PBS, ABC News, and CBS. Her commentaries have been heard on NPR’s “All Things Considered.” Ms. Mehdi is founder and president of Whetstone Productions, a New Jersey-based production and consulting company. She is adjunct Professor of Communications at Seton Hall University. She writes a twice weekly for the Newark Star-Ledger Newspaper blog. View her complete Bio?
SAFFIYA SHILLO is a peace activist, communications specialist and community editor for the National Arab American Times Newspaper. Ms. Shillo serves as a Board Member of the Palestinian American Women's Society. Her activism is extensive, having served as the former President of the Palestinian American Congress-Chicago Chapter, as a National Board member of the American Task Force on Palestine, and as Director of the Arab American Institute's Chicago office. Active in Jewish/Israeli-Palestinian dialogue, Ms. Shillo gives presentations to national organizations on strategies and methods to achieve peace through dialogue. Ms. Shillo also served as Director of Ethnic Affairs for the State of Illinois' Office of Lieutenant Governor, and worked as a domestic violence/sexual assault counselor serving Chicago's Arab community. She can be reached at smshillo@yahoo.com
ALADDIN ELAASAR is an award winning Arab American journalist and author of several books including Silent Victims: The plight of Arabs and Muslims in Post 9/11 America. Elaasar is also a member of the National Arab American Journalists Association. Email him at omaraladin@aol.com. His latest book is The Last Pharoah: Mubarak and the Uncertain Future of Egypt in the MidEast.
Veteran Award winning reporter Ray Hanania shares the secrets he learned from 32-plus years of frontline journalism to you can create an internet network that will allow you to side step the biases, challenges and failings of the mainstream American News media. Set up an effective New Media Internet Network bringing together web sites, blogs, social media, and create a strategy that delivers your message, product and opinion to the largest possible public audience. $34.95. 238 Pages.
More than 2.5 million Muslims from across the globe embark on a Hajj and converge on Mecca, Saudi Arabia, to ask pardon for their sins and renew their spiritual commitment though a elaborate series of ancient rites and rituals. And it's not optional - every adult Muslim who is physically and financially able to do so is expected to make the hajj at least once in his or her lifetime. Despite the enormity of this annual pilgrimage, it has seldom been witnessed by outsiders, as Mecca is strictly off-limits to non-Muslims. Now, with unprecedented access to Islam's holiest city, National Geographic takes the spiritual journey of a lifetime, following three Muslims from very different backgrounds - an executive from Malaysia, a radio evangelist from South Africa, and a blond-haired, blue-eyed professor from Texas - as they take part in an epic five-day quest for salvation.
Arabs first settled in Chicagoland in the mid-19th century, when immigrants from all parts of the world were flowing steadily into the U.S. As tensions in the Arab world flared, immigration increased—the first to arrive were Lebanese Christians, followed by Muslim Palestinians. Today, there are more than 250,000 Arabs in the Chicago area, with equal numbers of Christians and Muslims. A part of the fabric of Chicago, Arabs serve in many roles, from business leaders to elected officials to judges, doctors, engineers, journalists, and more. In the wake of the tragedy of September 11, 2001, Arab Americans have come under great scrutiny and have suffered much misunderstanding. Now, this book, which explores their integral role in Chicagoland’s growth, is especially important.
A collection of essays on the experiences growing up Arab and Palestinian living in a Jewish community in America on Chicago's South Side. Includes humor and anecdotal stories along with serious topic discussion. The first book to detail Arab American life first published in the United States in 1996. This 2nd Edition is published in 2007.
The ONLY directory of Arab American ethnic media -- newspapers, radio and TV. Plus organizations and religious institutions and more. Only $35 in PDF Format
CLICK HERE BETWEEN 8 AM & 9:30 AM CST
TO LISTEN TO
"MORNINGS WITH RAY HANANIA"
- LIVE INTERNET STREAMING AUDIO